Sweedish PC police strike again

topic posted Mon, September 24, 2007 - 2:36 PM by  Schrödinger'...
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
BRIDES are being told their fathers can't walk them down the aisle - because the practice is "sexist".

The bizarre ruling has been handed down by priests in Sweden - and traditionalists fear it may spread across the globe.

Is the tradition sexist? Vote in our poll below right and have your say below.

"In Sweden we have worked hard in many different ways to eliminate everything that is unequal," a Lutheran Church vicar in the Stockholm region, Yvonne Hallin, said.

She said she would not allow the custom in her parish, and noted that Stockholm's bishop issued a recommendation in 2003 that pastors discourage it.

Couples who marry "are equal when it comes to finances, politics, values ... but when they come to the church ... the woman suddenly turns into a man's property", she said.

Hallin said she has informed a father who was to walk his daughter down the aisle tomorrow that he will not be doing so.

The mother of the bride, who was shocked by the news, told Swedish news agency TT that the ceremony will go ahead as planned but the couple has had to give in to the pastor's wishes.

"In this case it wasn't the couple who became angry but the parents," Hallin said, adding that most people "don't find it strange".

AFP
www.news.com.au/dailyteleg...895,00.html
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

    Mon, September 24, 2007 - 3:07 PM
    Ridiculous. Already, those brides who find the tradition to be sexist don't have their fathers walk them down the aisle. What need, for legislation?
    • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

      Mon, September 24, 2007 - 4:47 PM
      I didn't think they were talking about legislation... it's in the church rules. That's why I don't belong to a church... they can almost say whatever they want.

      I didn't get married in a church. I didn't have a religious minister marry me. I walked down the isle with my soon-to-be husband.
  • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

    Mon, September 24, 2007 - 4:20 PM
    I'm having trouble finding Sweeden on the map.
    • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

      Mon, September 24, 2007 - 4:32 PM
      This giving away the Bride CRAP is dehumanising to Women!
      It's an early 1900's Concept who's time has come...and GONE!
      Human Beings do NOT 'BELONG"(are Not PROPERTY OF) either of their Parents and the Christian CHURCH needs to grasp this FACT.
      Once a young Woman becomes 18 yrs of age she 'Belongs to' NO ONE so No one has the right to 'Give her' to anyone else.
      One of my sister's 'allowed' this antiquated Christian Practice at her Wedding and the other DID NOT! She walked herself down the flower lined outdoor pathway to the Grape Arbor where her fiance was waiting. The other sister got Married in a 'Traditional Christian Church' along with all it's absurdities such as 'WHO GIVETH THIS WOMAN' and other Christian orientated Crap!
      • Unsu...
         

        Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

        Mon, September 24, 2007 - 4:43 PM
        <Human Beings do NOT 'BELONG"(are Not PROPERTY OF) either of their Parents and the Christian CHURCH needs to grasp this FACT.
        Once a young Woman becomes 18 yrs of age she 'Belongs to' NO ONE so No one has the right to 'Give her' to anyone else.One of my sister's 'allowed' this antiquated Christian Practice at her Wedding and the other DID NOT! >

        Which one is still married today? Anyway as I remember it from another discussion it was you that pointed out that marriage did not originate with Christianity, neither did the customs of it. So which is it? is giving the bride away a product of Christianity, or is Marriage a secular nonreligious activity? It seems that you are arguing from whichever side of the fence allows you to point the finger at Christianity, LOL! not that its anything new, but you could try to be less blatant with your hate speech.
      • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

        Mon, September 24, 2007 - 4:50 PM
        Jake, it's refreshing to see you in such a good mood~!!
        • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

          Mon, September 24, 2007 - 4:57 PM
          <--is always in a good mood!
          For starters Ricardo it IS your Xian Bible that states at Christian Weddings 'who giveth this woman away'? I never said MARRIAGE originated with your Xian Faith but the giveth of the woman away Did! and it IS an anti-Woman Practice becuase in Todays Society(unlike the Biblical Bronze age you still live in) NO ONE owns another person.
          as for my sisters? they are BOTH still happily married to their original and only Husbands
          One for 32 years and the other for 34.
          *Some*(a FEW!) Christian Marriages actually DO survive Divorce Court
          Although 54% of 'Good Christian Marriages'...do not.(taken from the current U.S. Divorce Rate)
  • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

    Tue, September 25, 2007 - 12:39 AM
    Oh pleez. Black Angus and anyone else who is ever tempted to take what the Cliftard says seriously, please remember he's a bigoted nationalistic proto-fascist who lies his ass off without the slightest hesitation. The scumbag has zero regard for the truth and will happiuly bendor break it. This is like his stupid Ben Affleck thread - trying to put down another country on utterly false pretexts, just to get his nationalist rocks off.

    Please people, before ever responding to this compulsive propagandist twit, check his story. In this case, the idea of some "pc police" swooping down on marrying couples who want to get married in the old-fashioned way is totally false.

    From the English-language swedish news site The Local:

    www.thelocal.se/8571/
    Brides' fathers banned from giving away daughters

    Published: 21st September 2007 14:29 CET
    Online: www.thelocal.se/8571/

    A priest in Stockholm has come under fire for not allowing a bride to be walked down the aisle by her father. But church authorities have defended the decision, saying that the tradition is foreign and sexist.

    The row started when a bride due to marry on Saturday in a church in the Stockholm archipelago asked to be given away by her father. The priest conducting the ceremony refused the bride's request.

    "These are two equal people, and being given away has never been a Swedish tradition," said Rev Yvonne Hallin, priest in charge of the Church of Sweden parish of Djurö, near Stockholm.

    The decision caused consternation in the bride's family. The mother of the bride, who chose not to be named, said it was an old tradition in her family for the bride to be walked down the aisle.

    "I think my daughter can decide for herself how she wants to do it. She's thirty years old and is extremely aware of equality issues," she told news agency TT.

    But church authorities are adamant that it was not suitable for a woman to be given away.

    "This symbolizes that the father is the owner of the daughter and that he is giving her away to her new owner," said Rev Eva Brunne, diocesan dean and assistant to Bishop of Stockholm Caroline Krook.

    Brunne told The Local that the tradition of giving away a woman was un-Swedish. Traditionally, Swedish couples walk down the aisle to the altar together.

    The practice of being given away "only came into our church in the seventies and eighties through American TV shows," she said.

    The Diocese of Stockholm leaves the question of whether to allow fathers to walk their daughters down the aisle up to individual parishes.

    "My policy is to talk to people. When couples insist, my personal reaction is 'that's too bad for you, but I'll allow it'," said Brunne. But, she added, parishes which completely forbid the practice "have my full respect."

    Rev Yvonne Hallin insisted that her church would not be making any exceptions for Saturday's bride.

    "I don't care what they do in other churches. Here, the couple walk in together," she told The Local.

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------


    And also a response to the original article Cliife posted (the first item to come up on googlenews, btw):

    www.news.com.au/couriermai...272,00.html
    I come from a Swedish family, and it might help the journalist who wrote this piece to note that it has never been Swedish custom or tradition for the father of the bride to give her away - in Swedish tradition, the bride walks down the aisle with her husband-to-be as a signal that she gives herself freely in marriage. As Craig says, a woman is "not property to be bartered for" - in Sweden, she has not been viewed as such.

    My Swedish father married my Australian mother in Sweden, and they walked down the aisle together - as have generations of my family before them.

    Different countries have different traditions, and the traditions that are followed here in Australia are not necessarily widespread. One should respect the customs and traditions of the country in which one lives. And frankly, if the bride didn't like the views of the church, then perhaps she should consider not marrying in the church.

    It is unfortunate that, in this case, the journalist didn't avail themselves of all the facts pertinent to the story. This is not news.

    Posted by: AJ 8:29am today

    -------------------------------------------------------


    So this what this is actually about is some people wanting to get a church to adopt a practice that is totally antithetical to its tradition, and the church refusing. I'm sure if the situation was happening in America and some couple (or couple's parents, as the original article seems to indicate) wanted a church to adopt some foreign tradition as part of their ceremony and the church didn't want to go along with it, our cliftard would have no problem with that whatsoever.
    • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

      Tue, September 25, 2007 - 9:50 PM
      <<he's a bigoted nationalistic proto-fascist who lies his ass off without the slightest hesitation.>>

      He's nothing compared to some people I could name who don't come around here much anymore.
  • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

    Tue, September 25, 2007 - 1:16 AM

    POLICE???? STRIKES??? and AGAIN?? Wow what a NON swedish expression... Typical MILITARY american term.

    We are not americans and will hopefully never bee, unless the TV and Movie (or YOUR militaryPOLICE) takes over our ANCIENT "hednic" heritage of beeing FREE women. Im so tired of this... either one should be copycats of "the american way" or then other cultures are strange? Well, who in america ARE americans from the beginning - the NATIVES, the rest is carried there with ships from mostly Europe... That young nation still wanna determine over other cultures, how come?

    I, and all of my swedish girlfriends, find a pride in beeing who we are without complex of NOT beeing wanna-bee americans.. We would NEVER EEEEEEEEEEEVER "LET" a MAN take our hand and pass us over to another man!!!!! *I wold kick their balls*

    This is my thoughts anyway... women in sweden DONT wanna be "owned" or "given away" by a freakin man... the thing is - this has started beeing COPIED from american cultures since its been seen in movies and tv-series, and I think it is STUPID that it should suddenly be copied without actually thinking MORE of what actually is portrayed...

    AND I am "christian", and I might wanna get married in a church, but no freakin way a dude is "giving me to another man" for christs sake!! AND the priests that say NO to this silly tradition suddenly beeing "romantically" copied from some sexistic shitty un-equal belief system are doing the RIGHT thing. We should strive to reach beyond that and not go backwards... women are free and so are going into a marriage, and both parties saying yes in a holy ceremony shouldnt be "given away" by ANYONE. I can give myself away, period.


    Whats ur problem Cliff? Wanna own a woman and give her away to some other man?

    Buy a magazine or pornomovie, and pass it over/send it forward when ur done then.


    Cliff - I know why you posted this... congratulations that you found something to stir up shit with and provoke, and "get even"?? since you think Ive posted things about your governments actions towards its own people... my god this is PATHETIC.

    Theres alot of shit that are sick in Swedens goverments and their rulings, there are egoistic politicians everywhere... alot of MEN think they own and should rule over both women and others will, money and that wanna dominated and control people. But NO way I will EVER - no matter culture, language or sex, let ANYONE "pass me over" or tell me what to think, how to live my life or threathen me into living as a shitty guy tells me.

    God, Lord or whatever you wanna call the King of the hierarcys top - which I am free to call whatever I want (my "Lord" is as the original scripture says and not translated into a male figure, darn it learn hebrew) THE ALL... and ALL and EVERYTHING is not ONLY male.

    Since that is the case, there is no MALE "overlord" or "king".... FOR ME... but I wont force my beliefs on anyone.

    But please, get a grip of ourself, and get over this silly "news"... there are more important things to focus on then that men arent supposed to give away their daughters in sweden.


    Why not dig into WHO killed our President/Premier Minister Olof Palme?

    Or what the "Swedish 911" was all about - sinking the Estonia ship with the deaths of several hundreds of innocent people...?!

    THAT would impress me... and shock me. So surprise me. But NEVER "give me away" to a man ; ) *yak*



    • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

      Tue, September 25, 2007 - 7:42 AM
      ***************I, and all of my swedish girlfriends, find a pride in beeing who we are without complex of NOT beeing wanna-bee americans.. We would NEVER EEEEEEEEEEEVER "LET" a MAN take our hand and pass us over to another man!!!!! *I wold kick their balls* ************

      Yah that was sort of like what you said earlier that gave rise to the impression of you being a Swede.
      It was from statements such as that from which I obtained the idea that you were living in another nation.

      So are you a citizen of Sweden?
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

    Tue, September 25, 2007 - 7:04 AM
    The whole concept of marriage is outdated. To argue about specific ceremonial things is like arguing about how many angels are on the head of a pin.
    • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

      Tue, September 25, 2007 - 7:40 AM
      Good to see some cultures coming to their senses and ending gender disparity, but especially as mandated by the American Christian/Taliban. To the Summerland with those people and their idiocracy aspirations.

      Genesis was a borrowed hodge podge of writing but they left out the most interesting character of all, LILITH, who according to the OLDE stories was Adams FIRST wife.

      LILITH was made from the dust equally with Adumb and all the rest of creation and was her very own autonomous woman and a good friend to Adumb. One day, as the story goes, Adumb was feeling a little horney and disrespectfull of the ancient art of enticement and seduction and tried to introduce some good old fashioned rape to the equation.

      Lilith beat the living shit out of Dufous and stalked out of Gawd and Adumb's garden declaring that she would fuck the demons on the shores of the Red Sea before Adumb would ever and never 'touch' her again''. Lilith did not find rape amusing.

      Sooo, back at the Garden, Gawd finds a desolate and horny Adumb, who coyly explains to his not so all knowing heavenly father that the ''Woman whom thou gavest to me would not do my bidding'', and Gawd says there there my priaptic son in whom I am well pleased, we'll make you a new woman who will be subservient to you,

      The rest, as they say is His Story,
      • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

        Tue, September 25, 2007 - 7:44 AM
        Actually Robin of Loxley, Lilith was a man eating monster. A harridan beast of a thing that the feminists have seized upon and given a make-over.

        Almost every single thing one may read about lilith is entirely modern and usually entirely false.
        • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

          Tue, September 25, 2007 - 1:22 PM

          Well no matter the history or its fake re-written made up fantasies - the future is quite interesting...

          I hope that no matter religion, women are free and allowed to either marry or NOT, and it will be under a ceremony that will please their spirit... but, I still dont support the idea to "give away" any women...


          Yep Cliff, I thought you knew I was/am born and living in Sweden?

          Anyways, arent all, or most countries, multi-cultural today... I am not ruling over anyone, and neither should a man, be it our fathers or the police OR the church-"fathers"... the essence of humanity is supposed to be built on the idea that we are equal, no matter gender..

          As for the biblical story, thats a too big issue for me to go into right now... it has gone on for thousands of years and have alot of "selfproclaimed experts" that know more then me, I guess.. "Im just a girl" ; )


          Peace. Out.

          And I like the quote: "No matter if you will get married OR NOT, you will regret your descision..." ; )

          • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

            Tue, September 25, 2007 - 3:43 PM
            *******Yep Cliff, I thought you knew I was/am born and living in Sweden?**********

            Then why did you tell me a couple of days ago that you were in Venice Calif?

            *********Anyways, [...] ruling over anyone, and neither should a man, be it our fathers*********

            It's my understanding that the special bond between a father ans his daughter are at the heart of the ritual.
            At any rate I don't think it speaks of giving a piece of property it rather speaks to some one stepping aside while another takes the place of prominence in the young woman's life.

            *****And I like the quote: "No matter if you will get married OR NOT, you will regret your descision..." ; )***********

            I can say without reservation that I do not regret it.
          • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

            Wed, September 26, 2007 - 1:48 AM
            Jess, maybe youre overreacting.

            You can assign any meaning you want to having your father walk you down the isle. Negative or positive-- it means what you want it to.

            Some women may see it simply as a way to include their father in the ceremony and show respect for his influence on their lives. It doesnt have to devolve into some uber-feminist diatribe about patriarchy or some other nonsense.
        • Re: Sweedish PC police strike again

          Tue, September 25, 2007 - 8:55 PM
          Actually Cliff, Lilith means beautiful maiden and almost all ancient accounts agree that she was Adumb's first wife and one thing that happens with every conquering culture is that the previous gods are turned into demons.

          Witness Pan's and Dyonisius's transformation into Satan at the hands of christianity.

          Litlith's greatest crime was the denunciation of monogamy best expressed by her penchant for luring good honest, heh heh , men away from their marriage beds.

          Patriarchy has a way of warping everything through the male dominance lens.

Recent topics in "! * POLITICS * !"